Greetings Earthlings! 🙂
This week I’d like to take a look at the portrayal of autism in the 2020 crime-drama film ‘The Night Clerk‘ starring Tye Sheridan, Helen Hunt and Ana de Aramas.
So what’s the movie about?
The Night Clerk tells the story of Bart, a 23 year old with Asperger’s Syndrome who works as a night clerk in a local hotel. Bart secretly films the guests in the hotel through a number of hidden cameras he has installed in order to observe people and learn social cues to help him navigate the world, becoming embroiled in a murder investigation as a result.
If you haven’t seen the film you can see the trailer here:
So how did the film fare in it’s portrayal of autism?
The film generally get’s a lot of the classic traits right such as struggles with eye contact, colour sensitivity, lack of filter, social awkwardness, stimming, coordination issues (in particular Bart runs awkwardly with his hands flapping at his sides) and echolalia. I particularly enjoyed Bart’s response when people asked him “How are you?” and he replied with “That’s a very complicated question!” As I’ve discussed in previous posts, I have often found in the past that this is one of the worst questions to be asked and it’s great to see that portrayed on screen.
Bart’s voyeurism on the other hand, while well intentioned, does portray the community somewhat negatively and further adds to the wealth of negative portrayals of autism. Interestingly though, it does sort of in a weird way shake things up a bit- yes it’s not the best look for autist’s, but it does highlight that just because you’re on the spectrum, doesn’t mean you can’t also be a bit of a creep 😛
Overall however, the depiction falls into the stereotypical pit showing us a lot of the same tired autistic tropes like Bart’s primarily monotonous tone of voice. Just once I’d like to see an autist show a little bit of varied inflection on screen- every single autist I know uses a variety of tones when speaking; monotonal speech is clearly not as common as film makers would have us believe.
Hope you enjoyed this post dear Earthlings! 🙂
Have a lovely weekend!
Hi. Thank you for your review. As an autistic individual, professional in the field of autism and someone who has supported hundreds of autistic adults, I found Ty Sheridan’s portrayal truly dreadful! Why in 2020, can’t an autistic actor be used for autistic roles?
LikeLiked by 1 person
There is an increasing trend towards casting autistic actors for autistic roles, but there seems to be a preference in hollywood to go for actors with some level of a following to try and draw in the audience🤷♀️